Socks in the dark
Show on board Only the task text, large and full screen – to copy onto the board or show on the smartboard.
The task (for students)
A drawer holds 4 black and 2 white socks. It is dark, and you take two socks without looking. Is it more likely that the two socks are the same colour, or that they are different colours?
Learning goals
- Find probabilities by counting combinations
- Test an intuition against a calculation or a simulation
Materials
- One whiteboard per group
- Optional: 6 blocks or cards in two colours per group to simulate
Hints if a group gets stuck
- Name the socks: B1, B2, B3, B4, W1, W2. How many pairs can you take?
- Simulate with blocks: draw two, put them back, and repeat 30 times.
Extensions when a group is done
- How many white socks should go with 3 black ones for the chance of the same colour to be exactly 50 %?
- Find other numbers of black and white socks where the chance is exactly 50 %. Do you see a pattern?
- How many socks must you take to be sure of a matching pair?
Teacher notes
- Intuition says 'same colour' because most socks are black. Let simulation and counting challenge it.
- Consolidation: list all 15 pairs. A good place to discuss why B1-B2 and B2-B1 are the same pair here.
Show solutions (for the teacher)
- 15 possible pairs. Same colour: 6 black pairs + 1 white pair = 7. Different colours: 4 · 2 = 8. Different colours is (slightly) more likely: 8/15 against 7/15.
- 3 black and 6 white give exactly 50 % (3 + 15 = 18 of 36 pairs). So do 1 and 3.
- Pattern: 1 and 3, 3 and 6, 6 and 10, 10 and 15 … – two consecutive triangular numbers.
- Three socks are enough to be sure of a pair (there are only two colours).
Licence: CC BY 4.0 – credit Tænketavlen. Task id: tt-028.