Tænketavlen Dansk

The box from an A4 sheet

Upper secondary (ages 16–19) · Upper secondary Mathematics · about 60 min · Draft – not yet reviewed by a teacher

The task (for students)

An A4 sheet measures 21 cm × 29.7 cm. Cut an equal square from each corner and fold up the sides to make an open box. How big should the squares be so the box holds as much as possible?

Learning goals

  • Build a volume function from a concrete situation
  • Find a maximum using a table, a graph or calculus

Materials

  • One whiteboard per group
  • A few A4 sheets, scissors and tape
  • Calculator or CAS

Hints if a group gets stuck

  • Try squares of 1, 2, 3 … cm. What are the base and the height?
  • Which side lengths for the square make sense at all?

Extensions when a group is done

  1. Do the same with a square sheet of 30 cm × 30 cm. Can you see a link between the sheet's side and the best cut?
  2. The box must now have a lid folded from the same sheet. How does the problem change?
  3. Prove with calculus that your best value really is a maximum.

Teacher notes

  • Low floor: groups can fold real boxes and compare by filling them with rice or by calculating.
  • Expected answers: somewhere between 3 and 5 cm in the table; a finer table or f'(x) = 0 gives about 4.04 cm.
Show solutions (for the teacher)
  • V(x) = x(21 − 2x)(29.7 − 2x) for 0 < x < 10.5.
  • Table: x = 3 gives 1066.5 cm³, x = 4 gives 1128.4 cm³, x = 5 gives 1083.5 cm³.
  • Maximum at x ≈ 4.04 cm with V ≈ 1128.5 cm³ (solve V'(x) = 0).
  • Square sheet 30 × 30: x = 5 cm (one sixth of the side), V = 2000 cm³.

Licence: CC BY 4.0 – credit Tænketavlen. Task id: tt-009.

← All tasks