Which taxi?
Show on board Only the task text, large and full screen – to copy onto the board or show on the smartboard.
The task (for students)
Three taxi companies each have their own price. Taxi A: 50 kroner to start plus 10 kroner per km. Taxi B: no start fee, but 15 kroner per km. Taxi C: 200 kroner for any trip up to 30 km. Which taxi should you choose? Give advice that works for every trip length up to 30 km.
Learning goals
- Set up and compare linear functions
- Find intersections using a table, a graph or an equation
Materials
- One whiteboard per group
- Optional: squared paper for graphs
Hints if a group gets stuck
- What does a 5 km, 10 km and 20 km trip cost in each taxi?
- Could a table or a graph with all three taxis help?
Extensions when a group is done
- Taxi B wants to be cheapest on trips up to 12 km. What should its price per km be?
- Taxi D wants a 100 kroner start fee. What price per km must D have to be cheapest on long trips under 30 km?
- Write a formula for each taxi and show the intersections with equations.
Teacher notes
- Table, graph and equation are all fine routes. Let groups choose, and compare during consolidation.
- Consolidation: draw the three graphs on the same axes. The advice can be read off as 'which graph is lowest'.
Show solutions (for the teacher)
- A: y = 50 + 10x. B: y = 15x. C: y = 200 (up to 30 km).
- A = B at 10 km (150 kroner). C = B at 13⅓ km. C = A at 15 km.
- Advice: under 10 km: B. Between 10 and 15 km: A. Over 15 km: C. (At exactly 10 km A and B cost the same; at 15 km A and C cost the same.)
- B cheapest up to 12 km: beating A needs 12p < 170, so p < 14.17 kroner per km; beating C needs 12p < 200, which then also holds.
- D: to beat C all the way to 30 km, 100 + 30p < 200, so p < 3.33 kroner per km (then D also beats A on the long trips).
Licence: CC BY 4.0 – credit Tænketavlen. Task id: tt-026.